tv State of the Union CNN January 29, 2012 9:00am-10:00am PST
"reliable sources." i'm howard kurtz. join us next sunday at 11:00 a.m. eastern for another critical look at the media. "state of the union" with candy crowley begins right now. florida, the tie-breaker. could give romney a second wind or establish gingrich as more than a one-state wonder or cause santorum and paul to recalculate. today, life after the sunshine state. >> there's a lot of enthusiasm for the cause of liberty, isn't there? >> politics with presidential candidate ron paul. a primary preview with florida governor rick scott. plus, working with the president. or not. with senate republican leader mitch mcconnell. and then wooing the latino vote with los angeles major antonio
villaraigosa and former commerce secretary carlos gutierrez. i'm candy crowley. and this is "state of the union." there are more delegates at stake in florida than any of the previous contests. so major momentum will come out of this winner-take-all state. naturally ron paul, a road less traveled kind of guy, spent the week in maine. >> what am i doing in maine? why am i not in florida? to get delegates. that's what we're doing here. >> truth is, ron paul doesn't need to be in florida to have a presence. >> the debt is certainly an important issue. you can hear it from the ron paulites who are here cheering tonight. >> that's the intrigue of the paul campaign. maximum commitment by voters in the face of minimal chances. his support now is too small to be a threat to romney or gingrich in the short run, but large enough to be a factor in the long run. and if ron paul shouldn't win, what's the price for his support? the texas congressman joins me now from his home state.
thank you, congressman. i just want to take a look at your -- >> thank you. >> -- strategy at this point which is to go to these caucus states where we know your passionate supporters will show up and spend time talking politics. where do you see a state where you can really break through and come in first? >> well, you know, after spending two days plus up in maine, i was very encouraged. the turnouts were fantastic. usually overflow crowds. tremendous enthusiasm. the other candidates aren't paying much attention. the interest was phenomenal. i think that's a real good place for us to break through. >> so you think you could possibly win in maine when that caucus comes up? >> i'm -- yeah, i really do. we did pretty well three years ago, and we weren't nearly as well organized. romney's been popular up there, but less so right now. so i would say that we have a very good chance. we're going to have an excellent
showing. and i don't know how many candidates really like to say, i am going to be in first place. most of us don't -- don't do that. i guess some do it. but i don't think that's very healthy. but i do really believe we're going to do quite well there and a very good chance of winning. >> this is not just a road less traveled, this is also a rough road for you on the way to the nomination. so difficult to put together enough delegates to actually win the nomination when your concentration is on just the caucus states. if it becomes apparent at some time along the road before the june end to the primary season that you can't get enough delegates to win, do you see yourself dropping out, or do you see yourself going all the way to the convention? >> no, i think we'll -- we'll continue. and it is a rough road, but the rough road isn't, you know, presenting our case. the rough road is competing with, you know, establishment money, the big money. you know, when you talk about
not a billion -- a million or two. we can raise those millions. but we can't compete with tens of millions of dollars for each individual state. and that's what, you know, came up in florida. you need a lot of money. so it's a money game. and i think that's one of the things that frustrates a lot of people. but, no, we're going to stay in and see what comes of it. and who knows what will come of the other two candidates. you know, there's been lots of ups and downs. so maybe there will be some downs and we might be able to pick up the pieces. >> surely there is always that. this has been a surprising primary season already. if you get to the convention and you intend to go there, as i understand from your answer, and if you have a large chunk of delegates, which is quite likely, what do you want in exchange for your support? >> you know, i really have never thought that through. i don't have a list, if you do a, b and c you're going to get support. i don't think people quite
understand that i don't control things. i deliver a message. it gets people enthusiastic. but if i leave the fold and say, well, now that we have these, i'm going to deliver these votes, we don't even think in those terms. and i don't think the people that have supported our cause think that way either. but, you know, i don't know how it'll pan out and what the discussion would be. i'm sure, you know, if we have -- if we have the delegates which would be on the margin, somebody's going to be talking to us. and i have no idea how that conversation would go. >> so without speaking for your supporters, speaking only for yourself, if you look at your three rivals now, could you endorse all of them? can you see your way clear at where they stand at the moment on these issues? could they get a ron paul endorsement? >> well, you know, it would be difficult. but they're not fixed on their beliefs. they vary. and they have their ear to the
political noise that they hear. you know, i kidded the other night, you know, in the debate, you know, newt is, you know, coming around on the monetary issues and really, you know, playing up and trying to appeal to us -- >> do you think he's doing that -- do you think he's doing that to appeal to your supporters, or do you think he's doing that because he believed it? >> i think -- you know, i don't know what's in his heart or his mind. but i think the politics of it all -- of it reflects the fact even if he believed it and thought it was still a crazy idea to quit printing money when you need it, he wouldn't say it. but evidently he probably has a belief that it does make sense and there's a political block out there. then i kidded, i said, well, i got you coming on the right way on money. maybe i can get you to come that way on the foreign policy and not want to fight so many wars that are undeclared. and, of course, he chuckled a little bit, too. >> let me ask you, herman cain who, you know, dropped out of the race but had a tea party
following of some measure, at least, early on, has endorsed newt gingrich. how significant do you think that is? >> probably not too much. i think sometimes, you know, we were identified with the beginning of the tea party. and yet the tea party is not a tea party. i mean, it's all over the place. everybody's claiming they're tea party. somebody like newt gingrich who'd been in politics all these years and an insider and claim he's leading the tea party, that's, to me a little strange. there is no one movement in the tea party. it actually started during our campaign four years ago. but it represents a significant number of people who are frustrated with the process as well as -- as well as occupy wall street. see, i talk to those people as well and try to bring them in. because it's the frustration level is so high, and i think that's one of the things that has energized our campaign. because our meetings and rallies we have are made up of democrats and independents and frustrated republicans and new voters.
everybody knows about the new voters coming in that were enthusiastic and aren't very pleased with what they're offered by the other candidates. >> congressman, i'm going to ask you to stand by for us a minute. coming up, policy with ron paul, including his reaction to president obama's strategy on iran. >> let there be no doubt, america is determined to prevent iran from getting a nuclear weapon, and i will take no options off the table to achieve that goal. [ male announcer ] this...is the network. a living, breathing intelligence that is helping business rethink how to do business.
in here, inventory can be taught to learn. ♪ in here, machines have a voice... ♪ [ male announcer ] in here, medical history follows you... even when you're away from home. it's the at&t network -- a network of possibilities, creating and integrating solutions, helping business, and the world...work. rethink possible. beth! hi! looking good. you've lost some weight. thanks. you noticed.
these clothes are too big, so i'm donating them. how'd you do it? eating right -- whole grain. [ female announcer ] people who choose more whole grain tend to weigh less than those who don't. multi-grain cheerios -- 5 whole grains, 110 calories. creamy, dreamy peanut butter taste in a tempting new cereal. mmm! [ female announcer ] new multi-grain cheerios peanut butter. [ female announcer ] new multi-grain cheerios for fastidious librarian emily skinner, each day was fueled by thorough preparation for events to come.
well somewhere along the way, emily went right on living. but you see, with the help of her raymond james financial advisor, she had planned for every eventuality. ...which meant she continued to have the means to live on... ...even at the ripe old age of 187. life well planned. see what a raymond james advisor can do for you. we are back with congressman and republican presidential candidate ron paul. congressman, you heard going into our break the president saying he would take nothing off the table when it comes to iran which is code for, of course, i'll use military force if i have to. he got a rousing bipartisan applause for that. after iraq, after afghanistan, two wars that all the polls show americans have tired of, does that surprise you that he got such a warm ovation for that
statement? >> well, i think they applaud the goal. that would be my goal, too. i don't want them to have a nuclear weapon. it's just the approach. if you would say i'm ready to invade and commit an act of aggression and go in and take over that country if nothing is off the table, when they say nothing is off the table, they're even talking about nuclear first strikes. so i always think the biggest danger is our overreaction. but if the people hear that in context that there's other ways to do it, if people understood what sanctions meant and that maybe -- maybe dealing with them in a different fashion, i don't -- they take one thing off the table and that is talking to them. and so i would think that if they understood that sanctions literally enhances the power of the ayatollahs and undermines the iranian people, because i have contacts with some of the iranian people and iranian-americans and they like what i say because -- and they don't like this idea of the aggressive approach because it
brings out the strong nationalism. just as 9/11 brought us -- our people together in a nationalistic way, this is what happens over there. so he needs to add something to it. but he's already taken off the table and too many of the republican candidates, they take it off the table, you can't even talk to them. but my argument is when the soviets had 30,000 of these, we didn't take talking to them off the table or even the chinese. we started talking to them and started trading with them and the results were much better. so i think -- i think unfortunately they have taken something off the table and we ought to reassess this aggressive approach to them. >> if you became president of the united states, who would be your secretary of defense? >> i haven't -- i haven't thought that through. i'm sure there are plenty that i could consider. but i haven't been in the mood to start picking and naming individuals. >> let me move you to the state of the economy.
the president got his chance to talk to the american people and give his version of what the state of the union is. when you look at the economy, had you been at that podium on tuesday night, how would you have described the state of the economy? >> well, i think -- i think the state of the economy of the world, because i think we're all involved in this worldwide because it's a dollar reserve standard that created this worldwide financial crisis, we're on a precipice. we're in a crisis. and we have to understand how it came about. you have to understand monetary policy. you have to understand that you can't have excessive debt. you can't run up a debt. and this is the crisis. it's too much government, too much involvement and that you have to cut back. but the answer's not all that complicated, either. if you do the right things, we could work our way out of this. but if we continue to do what we're doing by both -- the leadership of both parties over these last four years is more spending and printing money and bailing out people, believe me, we're going to go over the cliff. and i think that's what we have
to work to try to prevent. so the economy's in shambles but we can correct it by just sound economic policies which are not complicated. >> and let me turn you to another domestic policy issue. and that is, you had been raising money lately on your website on the notion of ending the tsa. most people know those are the guards at the airport that, you know, pat you down and go through your stuff. your son obviously had a run-in with some tsa folks when he was trying to get on a plane. if you got rid of the tsa, what would you put in its place? >> well, it shouldn't be government. you know, the people who protect very dangerous chemical plants, they're private sources, you know. they have their police guards. they have their fences and they have their security and they do a very good job. the assumption that the government has to do this is the wrong assumption. i voted against the department of homeland security and the tsa and it's a bureaucratic monster.
it totally voids the concept of the fourth amendment. searches and prodding and poking, you know, with no permission. and they trap us into it. there's no way you can travel if you don't do it. so i've said, you know, when you look at some of these pictures of prodding groin areas and breast areas and all this and old women having to take their clothes off, if we as a people are so complacent that we can look at that and say, oh, that's okay, they're making us safe. it doesn't make us safe. it undermines our liberties and there's a much better way of giving us security at the airports than accepting the bureaucrats and politicians in washington. that is totally unacceptable from my viewpoint. >> congressman ron paul, thank you for joining us today. we will see you along down the road. up next, foreclosures loom large in florida. will candidates' policies on housing come into play when republican voters cast their ballots tuesday? we'll ask governor rick scott, next.
per serving and are now weight watchers-endorsed. try green giant frozen vegetables with sauce. so i used my citi thank you card to pick up some accessories. a new belt. some nylons. and what girl wouldn't need new shoes? we talked about getting a diamond. but with all the thank you points i've been earning... ♪ ...i flew us to the rock i really had in mind. ♪ [ male announcer ] the citi thank you card. earn points you can use for travel on any airline, with no blackout dates.
voters mitt romney, 38%, newt gingrich 29% and down the line paul and santorum. looking at it from your perspective how is this going to shake out? >> it sure looks like governor romney's going to win. if i had my druthers what i'd want them to do, do what we're doing in florida. talk about jobs. i mean, our unemployment's dropped from 12% to 9.9%. that's what people are worried about. we've generated 141,000 jobs last year in the private sector. we still have 900,000 people out of work. that's our biggest issue. i wish they talked about that more. >> you have been pretty vocal in saying that all these attacks on governor romney's business past are counterproductive and shouldn't happen. it sounded to me almost like an endorsement of governor romney. is that where you're leaning? >> i just think we shouldn't be doing -- first off, the free market creates jobs. we need jobs. in this country and our state, we want more jobs. so it's good to have somebody that has a business background.
now, you know, i think the candidate that has the best plan for jobs -- what i did in my campaign, seven steps. everybody in the state knew it. seven steps to 700,000 jobs over seven years. so that's what i think they ought to be doing. they ought to say, look, whether it's three or five -- >> who has the best plan since you brought it up? >> i think -- they all have plans, all right. lower taxes, less regulation. that's not what they're talking about. but that's what the public wants. they want somebody to get up there and say, look, what we've done in florida, we're turning our economy around. but we need a federal partner. look, all the other issues are important. foreign policy is important. all those issues are important. but if you have a job, you're worried about losing it. if you don't have a job, you're worried about getting one. that's what they ought to talk about day in and day out. >> i also saw a poll, this was an abc news/univision poll that showed that 49% of likely latino voters in this primary back governor romney, 23%, a huge gap
between him and former speaker gingrich. why is that, do you think? what is it about the romney campaign that's attracting the florida republican latino vote? >> well, i mean, the -- the latino vote is -- look, the latino vote cares about family. if you look at governor romney's family, he's been very successful. he's built a great family. very committed to his wife. he's somebody that's been successful in life. so i think if they look at his background, it's what they want. they care about their families. they care about, you know, somebody that's been successful in business. that's what they care about. i think that's part of what his attraction to the latino vote. >> so that would be in contrast to, i mean, the family values in contrast to newt gingrich or to others in the race, you know? rick santorum, obviously, you know, espouses family values as well. >> absolutely. i think what's hard is it's not like you can have ten people saying the same thing. so somebody's going to have to be in the lead. in this case, i mean, mitt romney has done a better job -- >> it's that combination of
social values as exemplified in his life as well as the business background -- >> absolutely. >> -- that you think. >> i think about my race. in the end what they care about is tell me how my family is going to get an education for my children, how my family is going to get a job, and don't do things that raises the cost of living. you think about your family in florida, that's what you care about. education for your children, a job for your family, and keep the cost of living low so i can afford it. >> i want to ask you something that came out of the president's state of the union address on tuesday. he was talking about housing and in particular he was talking about those people who paid their mortgages, but who now find that, in fact, their mortgage is worth more than their house is. and he has a proposal for that. here's what he had to say on state of the union night. >> that's why i'm sending this congress a plan that gives every responsible homeowner the chance to save about $3,000 a year on
their mortgage by refinancing at historically low rates. no more red tape. no more runaround from the banks. a small fee on the largest financial institutions will ensure that it won't add to the deficit. and will give those banks that were rescued by taxpayers a chance to repay a deficit of trust. >> so a lot of these homeowners, while they have good credit, they can't -- they can't refinance to much lower rates because their home is no longer worth as much. what do you think of the president's plan? >> well, it's -- i haven't seen the details of it. but i think anything we can do to help homeowners is positive. there's two sides of it. how can we help them, but how do we pay for it? if you look at our concern, i think, in florida, we're paying down our debt. we've got a aaa credit rating. we're worried about the credit rating of the federal government and the deficits. i don't know how they'll pay for it. the things we can do to help homeowners in florida is worth
important. >> isn't it worth paying for it? there will be it doesn't look like a big taxpayer output but there might be taxpayer risk here. isn't that worth it when -- what are you, the third worst in the country in terms of home foreclosures? >> it might be. we don't know what it'll cost. here's my belief in florida. the way we're fixing our homeowner problem is getting people jobs. 141,000 more jobs last year in the private sector. that's what's changing our housing market. our housing market is coming back. my hometown of naples i think we're at a five-year low as far as homes on the market. there's places where we're doing really well. there's places where we're not. so the most important thing we can do is continue the track we're down. 12% down to 9.9%. hopefully this year we'll even do better and continue to drive down the unemployment and the employment. that's what's going to have the biggest impact. >> i want to show one last poll to our audience. this is approval rating for you which you know has been kind of in the basement. approval rating 36%, disapproval rating 49%. you know what the chatter is out
there, that there is worry by some anonymous folks that say he's going to be a drag on the ticket in florida. do you worry about that? >> here's the election. i'm going to have an election in three years. and they'll decide. ultimately in my election, it's what i get judged on every third friday of every month. tell me what the unemployment number is. now down 2.1%. second biggest drop in the country. that's how i'll get judged. the presidency is going to get judged on basically who can get at the federal level become a partner with what we're doing in florida. that's how the election will be. >> governor rick scott, thank you for joining us this morning. happy trails back to florida. >> thank you. after the break, senate republican leader mitch mcconnell on the chances of working with president obama this year. later, the latino vote. is it up for grabs? is either party listening? we'll ask two leaders in the latino community. i'm robert shapiro.
over a million people have discovered how easy it is to use legalzoom for important legal documents. at legalzoom we'll help you incorporate your business, file a patent, make a will and more. you can complete our online questions in minutes. then we'll prepare your legal documents and deliver them directly to you. so start your business, protect your family, launch your dreams. at legalzoom.com, we put the law on your side.
joining me here in washington, republican senate leader mitch mcconnell. senator, thank you for being here. >> good morning. >> let's start first with some congressional business. that payroll tax break needs to be extended by the end of february or people will see their payroll taxes come up. what do you think this final package is going to look like? we should say that the sticking point has always been how you're going to pay for this thing. >> well, there's broad agreement on doing the payroll tax holiday through the end of the year. republicans, democrats agree on that. as you indicated the problem is the paying for it. the reason we ended up only doing the two-month extension
earlier, candy, was because our good friends on the democratic side don't want to pay for anything. they'd love to do this -- >> well, they do. they just don't want to pay for it in the same way you do. >> they don't want to cut spending. they don't want to cut any spending. that's what made it problematic. we'll get it done. we'll get it done by the end of february. >> what will it look like? >> i don't know, it hasn't been negotiated. >> what's unacceptable to you in terms of paying for it? >> we don't believe that taking somebody's money and spending it on things like solyndra is a good idea. we think the government wants to take somebody else's money from people who've been successful and squander it on things like solyndra. we just don't think the government has this problem because it's tackixing too litt. we think it has the problem because it's spending way too much. >> tax revenues have been down. a certain argument for a later time. >> sure. >> but the question here is, if
there is -- would you pay for it partially with any kind of tax increase? would you agree to that? >> we have this problem at the risk of being repetitious, because we spend way too much. we now have a debt the size of our economy. we look a lot like greece. we're heading toward western europe. if you want to see what happens, just look across the atlantic. that's the direction we're headed in. under this administration, we've run the national debt up 43% in just three years. >> but you're not saying no, which is interesting to me. i mean, usually -- >> i'm not going to -- >> -- you'll flatly rule out any kind of tax increase and you're not. >> i'm not going to negotiate this agreement with you this morning. but i want the american people to understand that we now have a debt the size of our economy. and how significant that is. >> let me show you, and this actually loops into what we're talking about now. this is a comparison of president obama's job performance, the polling on that approval or disapproval.
it is now at 48%. so for the first time in a long time, in seven months, more people approve of president obama's job performance than disapprove. it has gone up steadily. a lot of people think that's because republicans overplayed their hands. that democrats have successfully framed republicans as standing in the way of everything for purely political reasons and standing on the side of rich people. would you accept that analysis of why the president's poll numbers are up? >> let me tell you what they've been doing. they've been trying to pretend like the president just showed up yesterday. just got sworn in and started fresh. in fact, he's been in office for three years. he got everything he wanted from a completely compliant congress for two of those three years. you don't hear him mention any of that. what he's been engaged in since the bus tours began last august is try to convince the american people that somebody else is standing in his way. >> but doesn't that seem to be working? >> well, the election --
>> according to those polls? >> -- is in november and we'll find out how people feel about the record of this administration. do they like the stimulus? do they like obamacare? do they like the new taxes? do they like the size of the debt? this election will unquestionably be a referendum on his performance. and he owned the government the first two years. he got everything he wanted. and, candy, there's no mistaking, we are living in the obama economy. >> i want to play you something from senator lee, who i know you know. who is upset with the recess appointments that the president made for consumer board and other things that he did while you were out of town. you were not officially in recess. but, nonetheless, the president went ahead and made these recess appointments. and here's senator lee on this. >> i find myself duty bound to resist the consideration and approval of additional nominations until the president takes steps to remedy the
situation. the president will not continue to enjoy the same nearly complete cooperation unless or until he rescinds his unconstitutional recess appointments. >> okay. so part of what the democrats have tried to do is frame you all as obstructionists. here you have a senator on the floor saying until you take back these recess appointments i'm not going to let any nominations go through. is that okay with you? >> we all know the president wants to pick a fight with congress. liberal presidents have always found the congress inconvenient. woodrow wilson thought the framers of the constitution got it all wrong and didn't make the presidency strong enough. franklin roosevelt tried to pack the supreme court. this president even more brazenly just ignores the constitution altogether. but we've had a good deal of discussion about the appropriate response to that. and we think what he's really picking a fight with is the american people. let me finish. there's already litigation regarding his appointments to
the nlrb. we understand there will be litigation regarding his appointment to the cfpb. the new agency that answers to no one. that will be in court. you can look for senate republicans to join that litigation as amicus, that is filing briefs in support of that litigation. and the courts will have to decide, frankly, whether the president acted unconstitutionally or not. >> so have you asked senator lee to back off here? are you going to allow -- >> oh, senators -- senators put holds on nominations from time to time. that's as common as -- >> do you think it's a good tactic here given -- >> it's been done from time to time on senators from both sides because they want to address some issue or some problem. that's not particularly unusual. what is unusual here is the president's unconstitutional action. in other words, asserting that he has the authority to decide when we are in session. i don't find that in the constitution. i think the courts are going to have to resolve this issue. >> you're not willing to tell me whether you think what senator lee is doing is a good idea.
>> senators put holds on nominations all the time. that is very common. >> a quick political question, senator bob dole who i know you know put out an editorial not that long ago, a statement saying he has huge concerns with newt gingrich. that newt gingrich is not qualified to be president of the united states. do you agree with that? >> i don't think the american people need any advice from me about the presidential election. republican primary voters are in the process of getting a nominee and i think it's going to be someone who can win. >> mitch mcconnell, thank you so much for joining us. we appreciate it. coming up, courting the latino community is a must for a white house run. a look at the growing hispanic voting bloc next.
ask me... even if you think you can live with your old mattress... ask me how i've never slept better... why not talk to one of the 6 million people who've switched to the most highly recommended bed in america. it's not a sealy, a simmons, or a serta... ask me about my tempur-pedic. ask me how i can finally sleep all night. ask me how great my back feels every morning. did you know there's a tempur-pedic for every body? tempur-pedic beds now come insoft...firm...and everything in-between... ask me how i don't wake up anymore when he comes to bed... these are real tempur-pedic owners...ask someone you know...check out twitter, or your friends on facebook... you'll hear it all...unedited!
ask me how i wish i had done this sooner. ask me how this is the best investment i've ever made. tempur-pedic brand owners are more satisfied. than owners of any traditional mattress brand... to learn more, or find an authorized retailer near you visit tempur-pedic.com. tempur-pedic the most highly recommended bed in america. at first blush, the hispanic-american community looks like fertile political territory for republicans. a pew hispanic center poll released friday found
three-quarters of latinos say their personal finances are in only fair or poor shape, and unemployment among latinos is 11%, far higher than in the general population. but on second blush, president obama's approval rating among hispanics is 63%, also far higher than the general population. [ speaking in foreign language ] >> former florida governor jeb bush warns fellow republicans, it's the word, stupid. >> if we do nothing to try to reach out to voters that believe in our values but feel turned off by the rhetoric, that is the dumbest thing in the world to do. >> and worrisome, too, for republican strategists looking at an electoral map where exploding hispanic populations have changed the dynamics in a number of swing states. when we return, the politics of ethnics. los angeles mayor antonio villaraigosa and former bush commerce secretary carlos gutierrez. inea pig: row...row. they genatectry, wch le me rf t.
guinea pig: row...row.took one, 8 months to get the guin: ..row.ow...row. they genatectry, wch le me rf t. lile cbby one to yell row! guineaig: ro's kof strange. guinig: row...row. such a simple word... row. anncr: t an easierayof strange. save. get online. go to geico.com. get a quote. e u 15% or more on car insurance.
joining me from miami, carlos gutierrez, who served as commerce secretary in the george w. bush administration and is now a member of mitt romney's hispanic steering committee. and here with me in washington los angeles democratic mayor antonio villaraigosa. thank you both so much for joining us. let me start with a little
something from thursday's debate which i think spoke a lot to the importance of the latino community in florida and elsewhere. the question was, hey, name me a couple of latino, a couple of hispanics that you might put in a position of power should you become president. here was the answer. >> senator marco rubio is a pretty impressive guy. >> senator marco rubio, a terrific hispanic-american. >> i actually thought about marco rubio in a slightly more dignified and central role than being in the cabinet, but that's another question. >> secretary gutierrez, let me start with you on this. this, to me, speaks volumes about the hispanic community and republican attempts to reach out. but it's not sufficient just to throw marco rubio's name around. not even in florida. what do republicans need to do to reach out? >> well, i -- i think as someone was saying before, you know, the values -- republican values are
so similar to latino values. family, faith, hard work, the future, building a better family, building better education, letting -- having an environment where the family can grow. that is very much republican values. the problem is, and i agree with jeb bush, is the rhetoric. the words. the words sting sometimes. the words that are used around the debate. and that has turned off hispanics. >> mr. mayor -- >> but there are so many things that we share. >> mr. mayor, is it just a matter of rhetoric? is it that the republican rhetoric is just off, it seems anti-immigrant, and if they just changed their words the more natural base for hispanic voters is the republican party? >> i don't think it's just rhetoric. in fact, i think actions matter. i'd say that american values are democratic and republican values. i believe very importantly that
the problem is that that party focuses a lot on outreach and not on inclusion. that it's important to be a party that is a big tent. america is a big tent. we come from every corner of the earth. our values should represent that and our politics and our actions, our policies should represent that. and i think when you talk about the question of immigration as an example, many of the policies that you see articulated right now in those debates are just out of the mainstream. >> like what? just specifically so i can get the secretary to comment. >> a pathway to citizenship. you know, the dream act. supporting the dream act. mr. romney says that he would veto the dream act if we passed it. >> the dream act allowing -- >> allowing people who have grown up here in this country, have gone to school here, want to go to college, serve in the military, give them an opportunity for a pathway to citizenship. it has to be earned. they have to get at the end of the line but they ought to be
able to qualify for that pathway. >> secretary gutierrez, i mean, it is true as we said earlier that most latinos identify at this point with the democratic party. what about the dream act? what about, you know, beyond the rhetoric? aren't there some policies here, this emphasis on sort of, you know, going to the border and putting up fences as opposed to how do we integrate the folks that are already here? is that a huge mistake as we move forward, the republican party, not just this election but years and years to come? >> well, the reality is, candy, is that it is all about rhetoric. the only party that has done something to try to fix the immigration system has been the republican party. president obama came into office with some grand promises for hispanics. it's been three years. he had the house and the senate for two years. and nothing has been done. what has happened is that immigration is being used as a political football.
it's being used for political tactics. so democrats bring out the dream act. just one sliver of the overall immigration piece, they put things in there, in that bill, that make it impossible to pass. but they're using it for tactical reasons. for tactical voting reasons. and the people who are paying the price are the hispanics who have their hopes up for the democrats to come in and fix these problems and they're just using them for tactical election reasons. what governor romney said yesterday, which i think is a very important insight, is we need to look first at our legal immigration system. we need a national immigration strategy, but we need to look first at the legal system. because the legal system is quite flawed. and that's why we have an illegal immigration problem. >> mr. mayor -- >> but the democrats have not done anymore than just speak about it. >> mr. mayor, does he not have a point?
the president campaigned saying in my first year, i will put up immigration reform. we are now closing up his first term and there has been no comprehensive immigration proposal put out there by the president. only recently has the president said, let's not look at, you know, the people who are not felons and let's not spend our time trying to deport those people, let's concentrate on the dangerous folks that are here without papers. has the democratic party been, you know, more -- more show than go? >> no. i think that's not true. >> well, what's he done? >> well, first of all, he doesn't have a vote in the congress. he's called on the congress again and again and again to pass not just the dream act, but comprehensive immigration reform. >> he could have come up with one, though, i think is what the secretary is saying. he could have had an immigration reform proposal. >> and he has. he has put forth proposals in support of the dream act, in support of comprehensive immigration reform, in support of border security, in support of the idea that we need to be
smarter about investing in the people who are here, but also creating as secretary gutierrez said a immigration system that addresses the legal immigration as well. the fact of the matter is that it's not just about rhetoric. it is about actions. and it's not just about immigration. i think the secretary would agree with me that latinos don't just care about immigration. that's one issue. they certainly care about education. they care about jobs. in fact, the congress right now doesn't talk enough and certainly doesn't do enough about the issue of jobs. and had it comes to policies and actions, it's the president who's helped to create 2 million jobs that latinos have right now. 6 million overall with the recovery act. so it's not just immigration. i would agree with respect to rhetoric, however, that some of that divisive, polarizing rhetoric that you see and hear in the republican debates are turning off a lot of voters,
including a lot of latino voters. >> secretary gutierrez, do you worry that that support, the hispanic community has for the democratic party, will solidify? >> i believe that with time, as we see more hispanic families entering the middle class, progressing, getting better jobs, a better education, you know, the way most immigrants grow. most immigrants groups. they're going to realize that what they want is to keep the money that they've worked so hard for, that they don't need to be dependent on the government. that will come. but i think it will take time. >> carlos gutierrez, a romney supporter, as we know, former commerce secretary for president george w. bush, and mayor antonio villaraigosa, thank you so much for joining us. >> thank you. up next, highlights from the other sunday morning talk shows. and then "fareed zakaria gps" at the top of the hour.
developed with dermatologists... it's clinically proven to remove 99% of dirt and toxins and purify pores. and with natural willowbark it contains no dyes, parabens or harsh sulfates. dirt and toxins do a vanishing act and my skin feels pure and healthy. [ female announcer ] purifying facial cleanser from neutrogena naturals. [ female announcer ] purifying facial cleanser this was the gulf's best tourism season in years. all because so many people came to louisiana... they came to see us in florida... make that alabama... make that mississippi. the best part of the gulf is wherever you choose... and now is a great time to discover it. this year millions of people did. we set all kinds of records. next year we're out to do even better. so come on down to louisiana... florida... alabama... mississippi. we can't wait to see you. brought to you by bp and all of us who call the gulf home.
at liberty mutual, we know how much you count on your car, and how much the people in your life count on you. that's why we offer accident forgiveness, where your price won't increase due to your first accident. we also offer a hassle-free lifetime repair guarantee, where the repairs made on your car are guaranteed for life, or they're on us. these are just two of the valuable features you can expect from liberty mutual. plus, when you insure both your home and car with us,
it could save you time and money. at liberty mutual, we help you move on with your life, so get the insurance responsible drivers like you deserve. call us at... or visit your local liberty mutual office, where an agent can help you find the policy that's right for you. liberty mutual insurance, responsibility -- what's your policy?
prepared to say things that are false. he would say thing after thing after thing that just plain wasn't true. and i had -- i don't know how you debate a person with civility if they're prepared to say things that are just plain factually false. he has a basic policy of carpet bombing his opponent. he doesn't try to build up mitt romney. he just tries to tear down whoever he's running against. >> the chairman of the republican party brushes off fears that the eventual nominee will be hurt by all this nastiness. until then, today comparing the president to the captain of that ill-fated italian cruise liner. >> in a few months, this is all going to be ancient history, and we're going to talk about our own little captain schettino, which is president obama who's abandoning the ship here in the united states and is more interested in campaigning than doing his job as president. >> while republicans occupy center stage in the political arena, the president's re-elect team continues to tune up, mostly on mitt romney. >> he has a great track record
of creating wealth for himself and his partners. and he's done it by closing 1,000 plants and stores and offices around the country. he's done it by outsourcing jobs. he's done it by profiting, by loading companies down with debt and then putting them into bankruptcy on which he and his partners made hundreds of millions of dollars. >> and surprise, surprise, donald trump says he's still thinking about running for president as an independent. a statement the democratic party chairwoman translated as a sign of weak innocence the republican roster. >> i think just the fact that he says that is emblematic of the unacceptablity of the entire republican field. >> just 281 days until the election, but who's counting? that's today's "sound of sunday." this week on the campaign trail. bill clinton was so routinely and so very late for so many events that reporters translated the schedule into what was known
as clinton time. george w. bush who frequently told reporters late is rude was so keen on punctuality, you could set your clock by his schedule. we want to thank "the new york times" for inspiring this election season's version of timing is all. supposed they threw a campaign event and the candidate wasn't there. step one: cue the music. ♪ ♪ i guess you could say >> step 2: who doesn't love music? keep it going. ♪ o say can you see ♪ by the dawn's early light >> step 3: trot out the surrogates. >> ladies and gentlemen, please welcome senator john mccain and the first lady of puerto rico, mrs. fortuno. ♪ >> congressman bob walker of pennsylvania, thank you for helping newt.
>> step 4: tap dance. >> what did you think of last night's debate? was that a -- >> how about we do this, as we wait for the speaker's bus to arrive, how about we chant newt! newt! newt! newt! newt! >> and in desperate times like the reliably late gingrich, step 5: rinse and repeat. >> let's have congressman walker come back up and give one more great story about his time serving with -- come on, congressman walker. >> they've played the waiting game many, many times. we are told that the candidate is in this hotel now. >> candy crowley is standing by for us in iowa, as she has been all night. >> reporter: we've been told that he was going to come out after rick santorum